Picking List Wizard and Pickadoodl are both free to start, and both put the pick list on a screen instead of paper. Picking List Wizard keeps it at that: a shared list your team ticks off. Pickadoodl checks each item with a scan and carries the batch through packing and fulfillment.
| Pickadoodl | Picking List Wizard | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Free up to 75 orders a month; $10.99 or $19.99 after | Free |
| Digital pick lists | Yes | Yes, unlimited |
| Mark items picked | By barcode scan, camera or typed SKU | By ticking them off |
| Sort order | By bin location, from a product metafield | By order or alphabetically |
| Team access | Admin, plus no-login work links in 13 languages | Shared in the Shopify admin |
| Packing check and fulfill | Yes | Not listed |
| Shipping labels | Pro, with your own EasyPost account | Not listed |
| Returns and restock | Built in | Not listed |
| Languages | 13 for staff screens | English |
| App Store reviews | New, no reviews yet | 5 reviews, 2.8 |
Choose Picking List Wizard if
- Everyone who picks has a Shopify staff account, and ticking items off is enough.
- You want a free list with nothing else to set up.
Choose Pickadoodl if
- You want lists sorted by where things sit on the shelf.
- You want a scan to confirm the right item, not a tick.
- You want packing, fulfillment, labels or returns in the same app.
Competitor details are from their Shopify App Store listings as of November 12, 2026. Prices and features change, so check the listing before you decide. Spot something out of date? Tell me and I'll fix it.
