Pickify does one job and does it cheaply: it turns your open orders into a pick list grouped by product, for $2.99 a month. Pickadoodl starts at the same pick list and keeps going, through scanning, packing and fulfilling. Which one fits depends on whether you need the steps after the list.
| Pickadoodl | Pickify | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Up to 75 orders a month, all features | No, 30-day free trial |
| Paid pricing | $10.99 (1,000 orders) or $19.99 (unlimited) | $2.99 a month |
| Pick list grouped by product | Yes, one list for the batch | Yes |
| Sorted by bin | Yes, natural order from a product metafield | Reviewers sort by a bin metafield |
| Export | Print, CSV restock list | PDF, CSV and Excel |
| Scan to verify | At pick and at pack | Not listed |
| Packing and fulfill from the app | Yes | Not listed |
| Team work links in 13 languages | Yes, no Shopify login | Not listed |
| Shipping labels | Pro, with your own EasyPost account | Not listed |
| Returns and restock | Built in | Not listed |
| App Store reviews | New, no reviews yet | 29 reviews, 4.8 |
Choose Pickify if
- You only need a printed or exported pick list, and you pack and fulfill in Shopify.
- You want the lowest monthly price for that one job.
- You want the list in Excel.
Choose Pickadoodl if
- You want to scan items as they're picked and packed, not just read a list.
- Your team picks and packs on their own phones without Shopify logins.
- You want fulfillment, labels and returns in the same flow, or a free plan rather than a trial.
Competitor details are from their Shopify App Store listings as of November 12, 2026. Prices and features change, so check the listing before you decide. Spot something out of date? Tell me and I'll fix it.
