BR Pick List Pro and Pickadoodl both build pick lists with barcode scanning at the same $19.99 top price. The differences are a free plan, how far each one goes past picking, and how they run alongside Shopify.
| Pickadoodl | BR Pick List Pro | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Up to 75 orders a month, all features | No, 15-day free trial |
| Paid pricing | $10.99 (1,000 orders) or $19.99 (unlimited) | $19.99, unlimited orders and locations |
| Scan to verify | At pick and at pack | Pick by scan or on-screen buttons |
| Bin-sorted lists | Yes, natural order from a product metafield | Group and sort by type, vendor, title, order or metafields |
| Runs in | Browser, plus no-login picker links on any phone | Browser, Shopify Mobile app and Shopify POS |
| Fulfill from the app | Yes | Yes |
| Shipping labels | Pro, with your own EasyPost account | Not listed |
| Returns and restock | Built in | Not listed |
| Purchase orders for missing items | Restock list export | Creates a Shopify purchase order |
| App Store reviews | New, no reviews yet | 31 reviews, 4.2 |
Choose BR Pick List Pro if
- You want to pick inside the Shopify Mobile app or Shopify POS.
- You want a Shopify purchase order raised straight from the pick list.
Choose Pickadoodl if
- You want a free plan rather than a trial, or you ship under 1,000 orders a month and want to pay $10.99.
- You want a second scan at packing, not just at picking.
- You want labels, returns and exceptions in the same flow.
Competitor details are from their Shopify App Store listings as of October 12, 2026. Prices and features change, so check the listing before you decide. Spot something out of date? Tell me and I'll fix it.
